89

I was drinking a glass of milk the other day and that got me thinking that no other animal to my knowledge drinks milk past their infant stages. One could argue that cats might but it isn't good for them to do.

Are humans the only animal that are able to drink milk as adults and not have it cause issues?

Of course, I know some people do have lactose intolerance too.

ggiaquin16
  • 861
  • 1
  • 6
  • 8

6 Answers6

75

Good observation!

Gene coding for the lactase

Gene LCT

Mammals have a gene (called LCT C/T-13910) coding for the lactase enzyme, a protein able to digest lactose. Lactose is a disaccharide sugar found in milk.

Expression of LCT

In mammals, the gene LCT is normally expressed (see gene expression) only early in development, when the baby feeds on his/her mother's milk. Some human lineages have evolved the ability to express LCT all life long, allowing them to drink milk and digest lactose at any age.

Today, the inability to digest lactose at all ages in humans is called lactose intolerance.

Evolution of lactose tolerance in human

Three independent mutations

Tishkoff et al. 2007 found that the ability to express LCT at an old age has evolved at least three times independently. Indeed, they found three different SNPs (stands for Single Nucleotide Polymorphism; it is a common type of mutation), two of them having high prevalence in Africa (and people of African descent) and one having high prevalence in Europe (and people of European descent). The three SNPs are G/C-14010, T/G-13915 and C/G-13907.

Pastoralist populations

Lactose tolerance is much more common in people descending from pastoralist populations than in people descending from non-pastoralist populations, suggesting a strong selection for lactose tolerance Durham 1991.

Selective sweep

On top of that, Tishkoff et al. 2007 focusing on the locus 14010 (one of the three SNP's mentioned above) showed that there is a clear selective sweep (which is a signature of past and present selection) around this locus.

They estimated the age of the allele allowing lactose tolerance at this locus (allele C is derived, the ancestral being G; see nucleotide) at around 3,000 to 7,000 years (with a 95% confidence interval ranging from 1,200 to 23,200 years) and a selection coefficient of 0.04 - 0.097 (with a 95% confidence interval ranging from 0.01 to 0.15).

I recommend reading Tishkoff et al. 2007. It is a classic, is short and is relatively easy to read, even for someone with only basic knowledge in evolutionary biology.

Are humans the only animal that is able to drink milk as adults?

I don't really know... but I would think so, yes!

Drink vs digest thoroughly

As @anongoodnurse rightly said in his/her answer

"Drink" and "digest thoroughly" are two different things

Pets

According to many dog health websites (such this one for example) claim that there is also variance among dogs where some dogs are lactose tolerant and others are lactose intolerant. I could not find any paper on the underlying genetics of lactose intolerance in dogs or other pets. It is not impossible our pets have also been under selection to be able to digest lactose as we humans could have given milk to them. It is also possible that pets do not actually produce any lactase at adult age but rather that some pets are just able to deal with having indigestible lactose in their guts! But then again, "Drink" and "digest thoroughly" are two different things.

Tits and robins in 20th century England

A funny and famous case is the case of blue tits and robins in the 20th century, in England. At that time, in England, the milkman was bringing the milk at home in the morning and would leave glass bottles with a simple aluminum cap in front of people's home. At some point, blue tits and robins learnt that by pecking through the aluminum they can get access to the milk. See this (non-peer-reviewed) article that tells the story.

Somewhat related

There are already a number of good posts on milk digestion in humans on Biology.SE. Consider having a look at:

Remi.b
  • 68,088
  • 11
  • 141
  • 234
  • 19
    My cats and dogs all drink milk when it's given to them. What about that? – ZzZombo Aug 14 '17 at 11:18
  • 7
    Can confirm the anecdote about small birds pecking a hole in milk bottle tops (around the mid-90s for me). Happened to us every so often. – TEK Aug 14 '17 at 11:35
  • 23
    Milk is a limited access food, and I believe that's the only reason adult animals can't drink it in nature. Suckling well is not a skill adult animals retain. Given the opportunity, though, many adult animals drink milk. Even chickens love milk! (I sometimes fed excess goat's milk to my chickens. It seemed to be a holiday gift to them.) :) – anongoodnurse Aug 14 '17 at 14:07
  • 5
    @ZzZombo Exactly so. My friend's father's dog used to be given a cup of hot tea every day, with milk, and somehow they had figured out that he liked it with one sugar. – user207421 Aug 14 '17 at 14:07
  • @Remi.b You're confused about who said what, and I don't know what 'typically' is doing in the sentence, but the dog concerned lived to a ripe old age. I could never figure out how they knew the dog liked tea, let alone milk and sugar in it. Just an amusing anecdote. – user207421 Aug 14 '17 at 16:10
  • @EJP Oops indeed. I removed my comment. – Remi.b Aug 14 '17 at 16:45
  • I just read that fascinating article about the tits & robins. The most interesting part to me was that milk used to be delivered with no cap at all, just open bottles. Really??? Cats, flies, birds, dogs, raccoons, possums, beetles... ahhhh. Yes animals will drink milk whenever they get the chance! Yes my biggest problem with it is that I don't want to drink ANYTHING after ANY of them! – Bill K Aug 14 '17 at 16:54
  • 1
    @BillK It is not so easy to reach the milk in a standing glass (let's assume the bottle would remain standing because of some sort of wooden box in which it stands). I don't think flies would be attracted to milk but I am not sure. Most insects can't climb on glass. There are no raccoons or possums in England (you North American fellow $\ddot \smile$). Squirrel sounds like a potential threat. I suppose that if they used to do so, it is because it worked! – Remi.b Aug 14 '17 at 17:04
  • @Remi.b: Just remembered another instance of animals learning to drink milk. When I was a kid growing up in dairy farming country (small farms, not the massive ones of today), the barn cats would wait patiently while the farmer was milking, hoping he'd squirt a stream of milk into their mouths. – jamesqf Aug 14 '17 at 17:38
  • 3
    @BillK That took me aback too, and frankly I don't believe it. This page on the history of milk packaging in the U.K. says that originally cardboard caps were used. – Alan Boyd Aug 14 '17 at 18:34
  • 24
    As a non-native speaker of english that wasn't aware of the bird called "tit", the last section of this answer had a very weird albeit amusing meaning. – T. Sar Aug 14 '17 at 18:47
  • 1
    Can confirm - I witnessed my dog recently trying to consume poop. Milk seems a lot better than that :P – Wayne Werner Aug 14 '17 at 21:52
  • @T.Sar you may enjoy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ueuA-9pqRok then. – Wayne Werner Aug 14 '17 at 21:53
  • 2
    It was actually cream rather than milk that the tits would take. This was in the days of unhomogenised milk where cream would rise to the top. – Jack Aidley Aug 16 '17 at 10:02
  • 1
    "A strong selection for ... in pastoral population" most likely means that if you could not digest milk, you died. – Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen Aug 16 '17 at 11:56
  • 1
    @Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen: As far as I can tell, lactose intolerance is merely unpleasant, not fatal. So if the choice is between eating dairy products or dying of starvation, I expect few people would choose the latter. – jamesqf Aug 17 '17 at 04:59
  • @jamesqf Lactose intolerance mean that you do not digest the milk sugar, which contains energy. I do not know how much, but apparently enough to make it a strong selection factor. – Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen Aug 17 '17 at 08:56
  • There's quite an interesting contemporaneous discussion of this, and other tit behaviour, in John Barnes' Titmice of the British Isles which was published in 1975. As the image in the linked article shows, it wasn't just blue tits but also great tits. – Bob says reinstate Monica Aug 17 '17 at 09:03
  • 1
    @Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen: Sure, you don't digest the lactose, but that's far from being the only nutritious substance contained in milk. Over time, it would create a selection pressure, but one far from a universal "digest this or die" elimination. – jamesqf Aug 17 '17 at 18:29
  • @jamesqf Perhaps. What would you then suggest could cause said strong selection pressure? If it is merely inconvenient and you don't die, you still reproduce. – Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen Aug 18 '17 at 10:31
  • @Thorbjørn Ravn Andersen: Just like any other selection pressure. They're very seldom binary logic. Just for instance, people might not want to mate with someone whose gut is rumbling all the time. – jamesqf Aug 19 '17 at 04:45
35

The problem with this question is 1) wording and 2) access.

"Drink" and "digest thoroughly" are two different things. The latter does not prohibit the former. It is only lactose that is not tolerated; Calcium and other minerals, proteins, fats, etc. are also present in milk and are beneficial to the consumers if the lactose intolerance is not incapacitating.

One could argue that cats might but it isn't good for them to do.

I don't know about this. My barn cats drank milk all the time without diarrhea or other untoward consequences; so did my dogs. Furthermore, feral cats steal milk, as do sea birds!

While censusing, satellite tagging adult males and rototag tagging weaned pups of northern elephant seals (Mirounga angustirostris) at Playa Norte, Isla de Guadalupe (14 - 19 February, 2003), we opportunistically observed the stealing of elephant seal’s milk by feral cats (Felis catus) and western gulls (Larus occidentalis). Western gulls have been previously reported stealing milk from female northern elephant seals in several elephant seal colonies... and this behavior has also been observed in other seabirds such as the Pale-faced sheathbill (Chionis alba), feeding on southern elephant seal (M. leonina) milk (Favero 1996). However, this is the first report that focuses on feral cats stealing milk from elephant seals.

Regarding access, how would most adults go about getting milk? If offered, though, many adult animals will drink milk preferentially over water if offered at the same time. When I had dairy goats, excess milk was fed to adult dogs, adult cats, and many adult birds (e.g. chickens, guinea hens, peacocks, etc.) The chickens acted like it they were children and the milk was free candy! (I never had pigs, but my uncle and grandfather did, and fed excess milk to the adult pigs.)

As noted above, wild birds will also steal milk when the opportunity arises. Cows will sometimes suck their own teats.

Humans only appear to be isolated in drinking milk as adults by their ability to obtain milk through farming.

http://www.scielo.org.mx/pdf/therya/v1n3/v1n3a5.pdf

anongoodnurse
  • 24,999
  • 3
  • 70
  • 99
  • 1
    That is an interesting point, one that a comment on the OP left me wondering how would other animals get milk since they lack the farming abilities that we have in general. So really it seems that it isn't that they don't, but comes down to availability and if they can get it from a source. – ggiaquin16 Aug 14 '17 at 16:38
  • 7
    I think access is the key. Animals evolve to get nutrition from whatever source is available. If there was "Milk" available some animal would have evolved to drink it. This would be very bad for the milk providers so the access to milk is limited (General "Milk Providers" would die out quickly and be removed from the gene pool). If we created a "Milk Lake" and kept it stocked I bet we'd evolve an entire new local milk-based ecosystem in no time.. this would actually make an awesome biology experiment. – Bill K Aug 14 '17 at 16:43
  • 2
    Piglets apparently can reach cow udders... http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/pigs-drink-cows-milk-austrian-farm-a7198756.html Not to mention orphans of many species will nurse from a surrogate, if available. But one of the triggers for weening is the adult teeth coming in (painful for mom!), so even if a succession of lactating surrogates was available, that might stop them. – user3067860 Aug 14 '17 at 18:23
  • I don't know how true this is, but my understanding about cats, and how lactose intolerance works for most mammals is that the animal will become lactose intolerant after the phase where they're feeding from the mother, but can remain lactose tolerant if they are still fed milk occasionally. If they go without milk from the time they're done weening to adult hood, they will be lactose intolerant, but will still attempt to drink milk when given the opportunity. – BooleanCheese Aug 18 '17 at 13:04
24

Just to point out an exception, adult cows sucking other cows' milk are not uncommon. At least, it's common enough to be a concern in dairy farms and for simple fixes to have been developed. The usual fix is just a piece of plastic pinned to the offending cow's nose that makes the suckled cow walk away.

I'm not sure of how much of this behaviour is feeding related, but concerns about direct impact on production make me suppose that inter-sucking cows are actually drinking a sizeable amount of milk - of course, there are also concerns about indirect impact on production by affecting the involved cows' health.

Pere
  • 586
  • 3
  • 7
12

Here is a bit of a tangential example, because it isn't milk from cows. There are some varieties of ants (Primarily the Leaf-cutter ant, if memory serves) which will collect, breed, feed, protect and "milk" aphids for the honeydew they produce. It is generally classified as a mutually beneficial symbiotic relationship, though one could argue that it is closer to domestication. The adult ants will eat the honeydew secretion.

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aphid#Ant_mutualism

The reason I bring this up is because one argument against raising cows in a "factory environment" is because humans are the only species that drinks milk after adolescence. While this was not hinted in the original question post, the wording made me think of this.

Thomas
  • 121
  • 2
9

Pigs can. At least one milk, and milk derivates, producer around here used/uses their own pig farms to dispose of all byproducts of production, overdue products returned from stores, same day unused milk, etc. As they owned the pigs, that should not cause too many problems.

I also remember a photo of depression era USA where a farmer is giving milk to pigs. The caption said that the price was so low that they used it for animal feeding instead of selling for human comsumption. I can't find it now.

At some times and places, butter was the primary reason for dairies. After the cream was skimmed off, the remaining milk had a much lower sale value. In some cases, it wasn't worth the effort of trying to sell it, or no one wanted it, and so it was fed to the hogs.

hhb
  • 91
  • 1
1

Milk (or food prepared with milk) is used to feed various domesticated animals like pigs or cats, also when they are adult.

h22
  • 407
  • 2
  • 8
  • That is correct, but this doesn't happen naturally. – Chris Aug 16 '17 at 13:39
  • 4
    The question does not say must happen naturally. – h22 Aug 16 '17 at 13:40
  • 1
    The way the question is asked, I see this as implied. – Chris Aug 16 '17 at 14:10
  • @Chris Yes sorry I guess it seems I may need to note that. Yes I am looking for NATURAL ability as in a normal part of their diet/food chain, though with today's food chain all messed up, who can say what is natural anymore for anyone. But yes, you are correct. – ggiaquin16 Aug 16 '17 at 15:29