How do you compare the strength of H bonds when it's the same atom on both sides of the H? Like $\ce{N-H\bond{...}N}$ vs $\ce{F-H\bond{...}F}$? Is one still stronger than the other, or are they both the same since in both cases the pull on both sides is equal?
Asked
Active
Viewed 1,212 times
1 Answers
4
In some cases, such as [F-H-F]- (biflouride), there is a symmetric hydrogen bond, with both H-F bonds equally strong.
However, just because the two atoms bonding to the H are the same doesn't mean it is a symmetric hydrogen bond. For example water dimer does not have a symmetrical hydrogen bond, the H is closer to one O atom than the other.
There can be cases where the hydrogen being exactly in the middle is a potential energy minimum, and other cases where the middle is not a local minimum but there are two minima offset from the middle.
See Symmetry of hydrogen bonds in solution for more information.
DavePhD
- 40,570
- 2
- 85
- 181