Given that electron affinity is positive, why don't these atoms attract free electrons and "prefer" to exist as anions? Never made sense to me — I could be missing something obvious.
Asked
Active
Viewed 263 times
3
-
3There are no free electrons, much like there is no such thing as a free lunch. Every electron belongs to some entity, which may be more or less unwilling to share it. – Ivan Neretin Dec 24 '15 at 21:30
1 Answers
2
Yes, the electron affinity for group 17 elements (group VII by older IUPAC nomenclature) is generally exothermic, so the uptake of an electron should be favourable.
But as Ivan mentioned in a comment, there is no such thing as a free or lonesome electron. Each electron must first be displaced from another atom — ionised; the corresponding thermodynamic property is the ionisation enthalpy. For every element, the ionisation enthalpy is positive, thus it is always unfavourable to displace an electron from a neutral atom. No exceptions.
Jan
- 67,989
- 12
- 201
- 386
-
isn't the first electron affinity of any element (except perhaps noble gases) exothermic? – Dissenter Dec 25 '15 at 03:14
-
@Dissenter No. Manganese, beryllium and nitrogen and possibly others have endothermic EAs – Jan Dec 25 '15 at 15:30