-1

I was wondering about this in class, drawing the structures of carbon dioxide and silicon dioxide.

Carbon and silicon are both in Group 4/14, but coming up with oxygen, one can only form a simple molecular structure while the other can form a giant covalent structure. I found no satisfactory in my chemistry textbook and online. What difference between carbon and silicon is this caused by?

luma
  • 1
  • 1

2 Answers2

3

Silicon is larger than Carbon, so Silicon's electron cloud is more diffused. Thus, if a hypothetical bond was formed between Silicon and Oxygen, the p - orbitals would not be able to come close enough to overlap enough to form a sufficiently strong bond. The bond would be too weak, and not enough energy would be released in this hypothetical bond formation, so this is energetically unfavourable.

1

Compare it to the analogical case $\ce{N≔N}$ versus tetrahedral $\ce{P4}$ with 3 single bonds per atom.

Carbon forms in $\ce{CO2}$ or $\ce{CS2}$ 2 double bonds, while silicon in $\ce{SiO2}$ or $\ce{SiS2}$ 4 single bonds.

Generally, elements from the 2nd period (C, N, O) have a stronger ( C,N much stronger) tendency to form double/triple bonds than their counterparts in the 3rd period ( Si, P, S), mostly because of better overlapping of p orbitals at forming $\pi$ bonds.

If there is bad orbital overlapping, eventual $\pi$ bonds are weak and multiple single bonds are energetically preferred to 1 multiple bond. By other words, forming hypothetical $\ce{O=Si=O}$ would release much less energy than forming polymeric $\ce{(SiO2)x}$

Poutnik
  • 41,273
  • 3
  • 49
  • 106
  • What about the analogous $\ce{CS2}$ and $\ce{SiS2}$? Is there something special about 2nd period elements making multiple bonds with each other, or is it sufficient to have one 2nd period bonding partner for a tendency to form multiple bonds. – Karsten Sep 15 '22 at 12:44
  • CS2 is molecular, SiS2 is polymeric, even if differently to SiO2. – Poutnik Sep 15 '22 at 12:51
  • CS2 is also notoriously unstable to combustion. – jimchmst Sep 16 '22 at 02:55