increasing area of circle,square &rectangle

Question

Recently our teacher asked us to arrange a circle, a square, a rectangle in the order of their increasing areas(perimeters are equal).

I found that circle has much area then a square.

But I was unable to find relation of third one.

Please help me to arrange them (with proof).

A square is a rectangle, although not every rectangle is a square. So the statement you gave is a bit confusing: do we actually have three different shapes? Did your teacher mean "a non-square rectangle" as the last shape? — zipirovich, Dec 25 '16 at 14:42

score 3 · Accepted Answer · edited Dec 25 '16 at 18:04

3

Let the radius of the circle be $r$, the side length of the square $s$ and the length and breadth of the rectangle $l$ and $b$ respectively. So, we have, $$2\pi r = 4s = 2\left(l+b\right)$$ Now, we have to arrange $\pi r^2, s^2$ and $lb$ in increasing order.

$(1)$ Circle and square: We have $\pi r = 2s$. So, $$\text{area of circle}= \pi r^2 = \pi \left(\frac{2s}{\pi}\right)^2 = \frac{4s^2}{\pi} > s^2 = \text{area of square}$$

$(2)$ Square and rectangle: We have $2s = (l+b)$. So, $$\text{area of square} = s^2 = \frac{(l+b)^2}{4} \geq \text{area of rectangle}$$ Note: The areas are equal if both the length and breadth are same otherwise the area of the square is greater. We can also see that proving $(3)$ is not necessary but...

$(3)$ Circle and rectangle: We have $\pi r =(l+b)$. So, $$\text{area of circle} = \pi r^2 = \pi\left(\frac{l+b}{\pi}\right)^2 = \frac{(l+b)^2}{\pi} > \text{area of rectangle}$$ Note: The area of the circle is always greater than that of the rectangle. We can easily deduce that there can be no equality.

So, our inference is $$\text{area of rectangle} \leq \text{area of square} < \text{area of circle}$$ Hope it helps.

edited Dec 25 '16 at 18:04

SQB

2,094

answered Dec 25 '16 at 14:27

Not quite right. The area of the rectangle is $lb$, not $(l+b}^2$. Redo the calculations before you get lots of downvotes. You'll get a different order. – Ethan Bolker Dec 25 '16 at 14:32
Sorry, I will correct it now. – Dec 25 '16 at 14:33
what is $(l+b)^2$ – Blaise Thunderstorm Dec 25 '16 at 14:33
@Rohan:how you claimed square-rectangle relation – Blaise Thunderstorm Dec 25 '16 at 15:07
@Blaise Thunderstorm Simple. See the AM-GM inequality for two variables. – Dec 25 '16 at 15:11
Part (3) is absolutely unnecessary. – zipirovich Dec 25 '16 at 15:12

user1131274 · Answer 2 · 2016-12-25T14:35:18.013

The relation is the following : Area of circle > Area of rectangle = Area of square.
Since perimeter is same (let it be P), the radius of circle is $\frac{P}{2\pi}$, side of square is $\frac{P}{4}$ and sum of sides of the rectangle is $\frac{P}{2}$. This gives us area of circle being $\frac{P^2}{4\pi}$ and area of square being $\frac{P^2}{16}$. For rectangle we have to solve the maximizing problem that is given sum of sides find the rectangle of maximum area which will come out to be $\frac{P^2}{4}$. To see this note we have to maximize $l\times b$ given $l+b=P/2$ which reduces to maximizing $l(l-P/2)$ where $0\le l\le \frac{P}{2}$. You can take derivative wrt $l$ and you will find that max occur at $l=\frac{P}{4}$.

Kanwaljit Singh · Answer 3 · 2016-12-25T15:20:53.663

Let's say the perimeter is 40.

Case 1-

As for the square, one side = 10.

Area of square $10^2$ = 100.

Case 2-

As for the rectangle -

a) Let's say the L is 2 and W is 18.

Area of rectangle 2 * 18 = 36.

b) If L is 10 and W is 10.

Area of rectangle = 10 * 10 = 100.

c) If L is 14 and W is 6,

Area of rectangle 14 * 6 = 84.

It will ALWAYS be smaller than or equal to the 100 Area of a square in above sub-cases.

So you can say Area of rectangle either smaller than or equal to the Area of square.

Case 3-

As for the circle -

2πr = 40

r = $\frac{140}{11}$

Area of circle $π * \frac{140}{11} * \frac{140}{11}$ = 127.27

So area of circle is greater than both.

Edit -

The area of a circle is $πr^2$, where r is the radius of the circle.

But r = $\frac{P}{2π}$, where P is the perimeter of the circle.

So the area of the circle is $\frac{P^2}{4π}$

The area of a square is $s^2$, where s is the side length.

But s = $\frac{P}{4}$

So the area of a square is $\frac{P^2}{16}$.

Since $\frac{1}{4π} > \frac{1}{16}$, the circle has more area than the square.

Edit - Rectangle and Square.

For Square perimeter = Rectangle perimeter 4S = 2(L + B)

S = 0.5(L + B)

Area of Square = $S^2 = 0.25[(L + B)^2]$

Area of rectangle = L*B

Area of Square - Area of Rectangle

= $0.25[(L + B)^2] - L*B$

= $0.25(L)^2 + 0.25(B)^2 + 0.5 LB - LB$

= $0.25(L)^2 + 0.25(B)^2 - 0.5 LB$

= $0.25[L^2 + B^2 - 2LB]$

= $0.25[(L - B)^2]$

Since (L-B)^2 is always greater than zero i.e. positive then a square's area is greater than or equal a rectangle's area with a given perimeter.

@Rohan it was typing mistake. – Kanwaljit Singh Dec 25 '16 at 14:37 — Kanwaljit Singh, Dec 25 '16 at 14:37
you have checked it not proved – Blaise Thunderstorm Dec 25 '16 at 15:10 — Blaise Thunderstorm, Dec 25 '16 at 15:10
you must not consider it a proof it is just verification – Blaise Thunderstorm Dec 25 '16 at 15:14 — Blaise Thunderstorm, Dec 25 '16 at 15:14

increasing area of circle,square &rectangle

3 Answers3