The question is find the remainder when $x^{60}-1$ is divided by $x^3-2$. My intuition is that this expression can be written as $a^n-\frac{b^m}{a}-b$. However, I tried a bunch of ways and I haven't been able to factor the numerator into that form. This is from an olympiad problem book on Higher Algebra.
-
what does a^n-b^m/ a-b mean? the standard interprettion is a^n-((b^m)/ a)-b – miracle173 Nov 24 '17 at 08:56
-
It means that. I'm sorry if it was unclear. – Prakhar Nagpal Nov 24 '17 at 08:57
-
$x^{60}-1 = (x^3)^{20} - 2^{20} + 2^{20} - 1 = (x^3-2)(\cdots) + 2^{20}-1$ – achille hui Nov 24 '17 at 09:00
3 Answers
$$x^{60}=(2+x^3-2)^{20}\equiv2^{20}\pmod{x^3-2}$$
Alternatively, using Why is $a^n - b^n$ divisible by $a-b$?,
$$(x^3)^{20}-2^{20}$$ is divisible by $x^3-2$
- 274,582
-
Sorry, I don't understand, it looks almost like you are taking 1^20 common from all three expressions x,-2 and 2. The two 2's I understood but how can you take 1^20 common from a variable? – Prakhar Nagpal Nov 24 '17 at 09:10
-
@PrakharNagpal, I have used binomial expansion $${2+(x^3-2)}^{20}$$ – lab bhattacharjee Nov 24 '17 at 09:12
-
We can use the remainder theorem. The outcome of dividing the polynomial $p(x)$ by another polynomial $d(x)$ is essentially an equation $$p(x)=q(x)d(x)+r(x)$$where the degree of $r(x)$ is less than the degree of $d(x)$.
Suppose $d(a)=0$. It follows that $p(a)=r(a)$. So one can reconstruct $r(x)$ by evaluating $p(x)$ at the roots of $d(x)=0$ (with an additional twist if there are multiple roots).
Here, setting $y=x^3$ we can simplify considerably by using $p(y)=y^{20}-1$, $d(y)=y-2$ and then degree $(r)\lt 1$ so $r$ must be a scalar.
We obtain $r=p(2)=2^{20}-1$
I mentioned reconstructing a remainder which is not a scalar above, because not everyone realises the remainder theorem can be used in this way, and these kinds of remainder questions have occurred in competition problem sets.
- 100,194
It is the same as if we ask what is the remainder if $t^{20}-1$ is divided by $t-2$ and $t=x^3$. So by the remainder theorem we have: $$t^{20}-1= k(t)(t-2)+c$$ where $c$ is constant. Pluging $t=2$ we get $c= 2^{20}-1$.
- 90,026