When defining some functions which depend on many arguments, sometimes we need to include predicate constraints (?xxxQ) to reduce processing time. My question is simple: is there a way to shorten a long function definition like this:
f[x_?NumericQ,y_?NumericQ,z_?NumericQ,k_?IntegerQ,l_?IntegerQ]:=Stuff[x,y,z,k,l]
to produce cleaner code?
You can use PatternSequence:
f[PatternSequence[x_,y_,z_]?NumericQ, PatternSequence[k_,l_]?IntegerQ] := stuff[x,y,z,k,l]
Check:
f[1,2,3,π,5]
f[π,1,2,3,4]
f[1, 2, 3, π, 5]
stuff[π, 1, 2, 3, 4]
PatternSequence with PatternTest would've never occurred to me.
– Sjoerd Smit
Nov 01 '18 at 10:18
Perhaps something like this:
allNumeric[vars_] := VectorQ[{vars}, NumericQ] (* define once, use many times *)
f[x_, y_, z_, t_] /; allNumeric[x,y,z,t] := ...
/; allNumeric[...] && allInteger[...] .... Feel free to post something better and I'll delete.
– Szabolcs
Dec 11 '14 at 19:04
Personal`" package where I collect little functions that I use often. I try to make an effort to detect repeating patterns in my work and package them up into small utility functions. In the long term this turned out to be a time saver (even though I have only a few functions in the package). The disadvantage is that it becomes harder to share your code with others (you'd need to give them these utility functions as well).
– Szabolcs
Dec 11 '14 at 19:22
One way may be to define global shorthand notations for pattern matching.
For example, I get the result
f[a_?i]:=2 a;
f//Information
(* Global`f *)
(* f[a_?IntegerQ]:=2 a *)
with the code
ClearAll[shortHand, shortHandReplace, shortHandReplacements, patternTest];
shortHand = {{i, IntegerQ}, {nric, NumericQ}, {num, NumberQ}};
shortHandReplacements = Block[{temp}, Table[patternTest[a_, term[[1]]]:> patternTest[a, temp] /. temp -> term[[2]], {term,shortHand}]];
SetAttributes[shortHandReplace, HoldAllComplete]
shortHandReplace[input_] := ReleaseHold[HoldForm[input] /. PatternTest-> patternTest /. shortHandReplacements /. patternTest ->PatternTest];
$Pre = Function[input, shortHandReplace[input], HoldAllComplete];
Basically, shorthand is a list such that any encounter of the first item in a PatternTest is to be replaced with second item before evaluation. For example, {i,IntegerQ} in the list ensures that even though we type f[a_?i], it is evaluated as f[a_?IntegerQ].
The function shortHandReplacements create these replacements, and shortHandReplace apply those to given input. I use $Pre so that this is applied to all input.
This shorthand works in the rules as well because it only relies on the presence of PatternTest. For example,
g[3]/.a_?i:>2 a
(* g[6] *)
One advantage of the code is that the shorthand notation does not affect the code outside so using these shortcuts is no-means a limitation on these variables:
ClearAll[f];
f[i_?i]:=Cos[i]
?f
(* Global`f *)
(* f[i_?IntegerQ]:=Cos[i] *)
Another advantage of the code is that we can arbitrarily define tests and shorthand notations for them easily. For example:
ClearAll[divisibleByThreeQ,divisibleBySevenQ];
divisibleByThreeQ=(Divisible[#,3]&);
divisibleBySevenQ=(Divisible[#,7]&);
shortHand={{i,IntegerQ},{nric,NumericQ},{num,NumberQ},{d3,divisibleBySevenQ},{d7,divisibleBySevenQ}};
allows us to define
ClearAll[j];
j[a_?d3,b_?d7]:=a+b;
?j
(* Global`j *)
(* j[a_?(Divisible[#1,3]&),b_?(Divisible[#1,7]&)]:=a+b *)
num = NumericQ. Shorter but not necessarily easier to follow for other users. – John Morganthau Dec 11 '14 at 19:00f[numlist : {_?NumericQ ..}] := Module[{x, y, z, k, l}, {x, y, z, k, l} = numlist; ...]. – Daniel Lichtblau Dec 11 '14 at 19:04