for questions related to peer review, such as transparency, best practices and ethical issues; cf. also [tag:journals].
Questions tagged [peer-review]
28 questions
21
votes
2 answers
MathScinet reviewing: should I check the proofs?
The guidelines do not clearly specify how much work one is assumed to do in writing a MathSciNet review. What is the consensus? Is one expected to read the whole paper and check the the proofs in detail?
Valentas
- 253