4

A changing magnetic field pierces the interior of a circuit containing three identical resistors. Two voltmeters are connected to the same points, as shown. V1 reads 1 mV. What does V2 read?

enter image description here

Apparently the answer was 2 mV but I don't understand why the answer isn't still 1 mV. Since the voltmeters are connected to the same points shouldn't they give the same reading? How does the magnetic field change anything?

  • This is a standard problem to illustrate why, in ideal circuit theory, it is assumed that there are no changing magnetic fields threading the circuit. Since there is a changing magnetic field threading this circuit, the voltage between two points is path dependent. Related: http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/30446/9887 – Alfred Centauri Apr 22 '15 at 12:40
  • It might be worth you looking at this video at about 5 minutes from the start? https://archive.org/details/MIT8.02S02? – Farcher Apr 17 '16 at 06:49

1 Answers1

1

Both voltmeters are indeed connected to the same endpoints, but if the system contains changing magnetic fields then it is no longer true that this implies that they must read the same voltage.

Instead, their difference $V_2-V_1$ measures the line integral of the electric field along the outermost wire loop (i.e. the one including both voltmeters and no resistors), and this in turn is specified by Faraday's law of magnetic induction to be the rate of change of magnetic flux inside the loop: $$ V_2-V_1=\oint_C \mathbf E\cdot \mathrm d \mathbf r=-\frac{\mathrm d}{\mathrm dt}\iint_{\text{int}(C)}\mathbf B\cdot \mathrm d\mathbf S=-\frac{\mathrm d \Phi}{\mathrm dt}. $$

If the rate of change in magnetic flux is nonzero, $V_2$ and $V_1$ will be different.

To find out what this difference is, you need more information on $\frac{\mathrm d \Phi}{\mathrm dt}$. This can be obtained from the inner loop (i.e. the one with three resistors), as there the EMF is balanced by the ohmic voltage of the resistors, from which you can find the current in that loop. Once you do that, applying Faraday's law to the two outer loops (with a mix of voltmeters and resistors, but no magnetic field) will give you the measured voltages.

Emilio Pisanty
  • 132,859
  • 33
  • 351
  • 666