2

I have a question regarding the attenuation of x-ray radiation in a Medium. Let us Assume we have a phantom like this:

Medium

The darker the gray, the higher is the attenuation of x-ray radiation of the material in that region.

Now let us further assume that there is and x-ray source on the left side of the phantom, and a detector pane on the right. We now measure the Intensity of radiation that travels through the volume from left to right. Now both the x-ray source and the detector swap positions with each other, and we measure the Intensity of radiation traveling through the volume from right to left.

My question is: Do the Intensity values differ from another? And if yes, what exactly causes this?

PKlumpp
  • 193

2 Answers2

3

If we set the attenuation per unit length of each of the $n$ segments as $\mu_i$, and they have a length $\ell_i$, then the transmitted intensity is

$$I_t = I_0 e^{-\mu_1 \ell_1}\cdot e^{-\mu_2 \ell_2} ... = I_0 \prod_{i=1}^{n} e^{-\mu_i \ell_i} = I_0 e^{-\sum{\mu_i \ell_i}}$$

The value of this expression is the same whether you evaluate from $i=1$ to $i=n$, or start at $i=n$ and work down to $i=1$. So the simple answer is - it doesn't matter whether the beam goes left to right, or right to left.

However - it is possible that you will observe a different intensity on your detector, depending on the materials used and the experimental setup.

The reason for this is scatter: for a given energy of X-ray, atoms of a particular Z have a certain probability of (Compton) scattering the incident radiation, rather than absorbing with photo-electric absorption. In Compton scatter, the photon continues with reduced energy and a new direction; with photo-electric absorption, the full energy of the photon is absorbed so it disappears. There is also a small probability of coherent scatter (without loss of energy) and, at very high energies, of pair production; but for medical X-rays (20 - 120 keV) and for most common materials, the dominant mechanisms are Compton and photo-electric interactions.

Now if your detector is not well shielded / collimated, it can detect radiation from any direction; if your first block in the attenuator is a low Z material (lots of scatter), then a certain amount of scatter will reach the walls of the room and scatter back to the detector; if turning the block around, you start with a high Z material (little scatter), then few of the X-rays that reach the low Z material will have this alternative path available.

This effect will only matter if you have a poorly shielded detector and "other stuff" (besides the attenuator you drew) in your setup. But in reality, you usually have a bench, walls, etc. So it is something worth keeping in mind.

Floris
  • 118,905
2

Intensities shouldn't differ. Say, one block lets through 0.9 of incoming light, another 0.5 and so on. The intensity of transmitted light is the product of individual transmittances (0.9*0.5*...) and it will not depend on the order of the blocks.

gigacyan
  • 4,690