Subfigure labelling for a single figure with REVTeX 4.2

Question

Look at this piece of paper from an APS journal:

as you can see there is a single image (called figure 3) with already embedded the (a), (b), etc.. letters indicating different parts of the same figure. If you look above it you can see they are able to reference the single parts of the figure (e.g. fig. 3(b)), but how is possible to do that since they don't have subfigures? My guessing was they were using phantom captions from the subcaption package, but this is not possible since this latter is not compatible with REVTeX 4.2 (that is the standard document package for APS journals). My question is: how can I obtain the same result?

Here you can find a Minimal Working Example of my attempt:

\documentclass{revtex4-2}
\usepackage[colorlinks,linkcolor=red,citecolor=red,urlcolor=red]{hyperref}
\usepackage[demo]{graphicx}

\begin{document}
    \begin{figure}
    \centering
    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{example-image-a}
\caption{Main caption here}
\label{fig:main}
\end{figure}

Suppose that figure \ref{fig:main} is already divided in part (a) and part (b). I want to reference part \ref{fig:main}a and part \ref{fig:main}b, but if I do like this only the number is \textit{clickable}, not the letter. Moreover I have to write manually the letter. A workaround I have found is \hyperref[fig:main]{\ref{fig:main}a}, but I am still not satisfied because I still have to write the letter manually.

\end{document}

Answer 1

Here is an elegant solution I have found. It produces the output as in the example provided as the desired output.

\documentclass{revtex4-2}
\usepackage[colorlinks,linkcolor=red,citecolor=red,urlcolor=red]{hyperref}
\usepackage[demo]{graphicx}
\usepackage[capitalize]{cleveref}
% \usepackage{subcaption} % Incompatible with revtex4-2
\usepackage[caption=false]{subfig}
% Keep the parentheses like in \subref but allow to use cleveref
\captionsetup[subfigure]{subrefformat=simple,labelformat=simple,listofformat=subsimple}
\renewcommand\thesubfigure{(\alph{subfigure})}
% Allows referencing phantom subfigures, i.e. when (a), (b) are part of an
% image itself. Must be followed by \vspace{-2\baselineskip}
\newcommand{\phantomsubfloat}[1]{
    {% apply caption setup only temporarily
        \captionsetup[subfigure]{labelformat=empty}
        \subfloat[][]{#1}
    }%
}
\begin{document}
\begin{figure}
    \centering
    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{example-image-a}
    % Keep above the caption to avoid messing up counters
    \phantomsubfloat{\label{fig:main_spaced_a}}
    \phantomsubfloat{\label{fig:main_spaced_b}}
    \phantomsubfloat{\label{fig:main_spaced_c}}
    \caption{
    Using empty subfloat gets half the job done, but there is too much space between the image and the main caption
    \label{fig:main_spaced}
    }
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
    \centering
    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{example-image-a}
    % Keep above the caption to avoid messing up counters
    \phantomsubfloat{\label{fig:main_a}}
    \phantomsubfloat{\label{fig:main_b}}
    \phantomsubfloat{\label{fig:main_c}}
    \vspace{-2\baselineskip}% Remove extra line inserted by subfloat
    \caption{
    But it can be elegantly removed!
    \label{fig:main}
    }
\end{figure}
\begin{figure}
    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{example-image-a}
    % Keep above the caption to avoid messing up counters
    \phantomsubfloat{\label{fig:justified_a}}
    \phantomsubfloat{\label{fig:justified_b}}
    \phantomsubfloat{\label{fig:justified_c}}
    \vspace{-2\baselineskip}% Remove extra line inserted by subfloat
    \caption{
    If caption centering is not desired you will find issues when trying to use the caption or subcaption packages (as several other solutions propose). But this solution keeps things elegant.
    \label{fig:justified}
    }
\end{figure}
You can now simply reference~\cref{fig:main_a}. \Cref{fig:main_a,fig:main_b,fig:main_c} can all be referenced now.
\end{document}

Result:

Answer 2

I do not think this answer is really relevant for anyone after 4 years. But as an author of the paper in question I can say that we had just

Figures~\ref{fig:dia}(b) and~(e) show the two limiting cases

in our original LaTeX file without any tweaks. APS currently converts LaTeX submissions to XML and then XML to pdf. I guess the hyperlinks to Fig. 3(b) and Fig. 3(e) were made at the automatic LaTeX to XML conversion stage.

Answer 3

Improving on the answer of caenrigen, by removing the need to add manually after the command \phantomsubfloat the command \vspace{-2\baselineskip}.

\usepackage[caption=false]{subfig}
\captionsetup[subfigure]{subrefformat=simple,labelformat=simple,listofformat=subsimple}
% Allows referencing phantom subfigures, i.e. when (a), (b) are part of an
% image itself. 
\newcommand{\phantomsubfloat}[1]{
    {% apply caption setup only temporarily
        \captionsetup[subfloat]{farskip=0pt,captionskip=0pt}
        \captionsetup[subfigure]{labelformat=empty}
        \subfloat{#1}
    }%
}

Answer 4

\documentclass{revtex4-2}
\usepackage{tabularx}
\usepackage[labelformat=simple]{subcaption}
\renewcommand\thesubfigure{(\alph{subfigure})}
\usepackage{graphicx}

\begin{document}
    \begin{figure}[htb]
    \captionsetup[subfigure]{singlelinecheck=off}
\begin{tabularx}{\linewidth}{*{3}{X}}
\begin{subfigure}[b]{\linewidth}
\caption{}\label{subfig:a}
\includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{example-image-duck}
\end{subfigure}
&
\begin{subfigure}[b]{\linewidth}
\caption{}\label{subfig:b}
\includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{example-image-duck}
\end{subfigure}
&
\begin{subfigure}[b]{\linewidth}
\caption{}\label{subfig:b}
\includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{example-image-duck}
\end{subfigure}
                                \\
coordinate image & coordinate image & coordinate image   \\
type             & type             & type
\end{tabularx}
    \caption{some long text}
    \label{fig:a}
\end{figure}
see \ref{subfig:a}
\end{document}

gives

note: since you not provide mwe, i didn't bother with table looks. i focused only on your question. coloring and lines you can add yourself.

Answer 5

Note that I only have REVTex4-1, I however assume the solution works also for REVTex4-2.

I achieved the results using a hacky tikz solution. We use tikz to draw over the original plot. As subcaption is not available for REVTex, we use an empty subfig.

We first make an environment:

\newenvironment{captivy}[1]{%SETUP
  \begin{tikzpicture}[every node/.style={inner sep=0}]
    \node[anchor=south west,inner sep=0] (image) at (0,0) {#1};
    \begin{scope}[x={(image.south east)},y={(image.north west)}]
}%
{%TEARDOWN
        \end{scope}%
  \pgfresetboundingbox
  \path[use as bounding box] (image.south west) rectangle (image.north east);
  \end{tikzpicture}%
}

This includes our figure given as argument #1 on a tikz picture. The last two lines in tikzpicture are about the bounding box, that we don't create additional whitespace.

Next we create a command to creat captions within this environment:

\newcommand*{\oversubcaption}[3]{%
  \draw (#1) node[fill=white,inner sep=0pt, opacity=0.2, above, yscale=1.1, xscale=1.1] {\phantom{(a)#2}};
  \draw (#1) node[inner sep=0pt, above]{%
    \subfloat[#2\label{#3}]{\phantom{(a)}}
    %   % \subcaption{#2}\label{#3}
  };
}

As we cannot use \subcaption, we replaced it by \subfloat. We put the empty image \phantom(a), and add the label argument #3. Addtionally we can provide a caption #2. The first argument #1 specifies the position of the caption and label. (The first line adds a transparent background, you can omit it if you don't like it.)

The rest of the document would then be

\documentclass{revtex4-1}
\usepackage{tikz}
\usepackage{graphicx}
\usepackage[caption=false]{subfig}
\usepackage[colorlinks,linkcolor=red,citecolor=red,urlcolor=red]{hyperref}


\begin{document}
\begin{figure}
  \centering
  \begin{captivy}{\includegraphics[width=.5\textwidth]{example-image-a}}
    \oversubcaption{0.2, 0.9}{}{fig:suba}
    \oversubcaption{0.7, 0.9}{}{fig:subb}
  \end{captivy}
  \caption{Main caption here}
  \label{fig:main}
\end{figure}

Suppose that figure \ref{fig:main} is already divided in part \subref{fig:suba} and part \subref{fig:subb}.
I want to reference part \ref{fig:suba} and part \ref{fig:subb}, but if I do like this only the number is \textit{clickable}, not the letter.
Moreover I have to write manually the letter.
A workaround I have found is \hyperref[fig:main]{\ref{fig:main}a}, but I am still not satisfied because I still have to write the letter manually.

\end{document}