4

I'd like to write natural transformation arrows in LyX (2.0.5.1) using 2cell (see this answer). The problem is, LyX seems to include the xy package by default and it's only using the [all] option. I can't find a way to change the options or disable the package alltogether, and if I use the xy package with the [all,2cell] options in the document preamble I get complaints about loading the package twice. Is there a (nice) way around this?

EDIT: As pointed out in the comments, LyX adds the xy package automatically when I use \xymatrix in the document. Can this be disabled or can I change which options are used for the package?

Community
  • 1
nonpop
  • 153
  • LyX does not, to my knowledge, load xy by default, have you included any modules, or done anything else to be able to use it? You can try adding 2cell to the custom document class options, in Document --> Settings --> Document Class. – Torbjørn T. Feb 08 '13 at 08:42
  • @TorbjørnT: I tried creating a new document, set the document class to article, unselected all modules, cleared the LaTeX preamble, and finally clicked 'Use Class Defaults'. I'm still able to use xy in the document and there is indeed a \usepackage[all]{xy} in the preamble of the source. I don't remember doing anything to make it go there... I tried putting 2cell to document class options but it didn't help. – nonpop Feb 08 '13 at 08:57
  • 1
    I guess, LyX does not load it by default, but if you use it inside your LyX document, automatically adds the \usepackage[all]{xy} to the preamble. – Daniel Feb 08 '13 at 09:06
  • @Daniel: You're right! Now I wonder how to suppress this behavior. – nonpop Feb 08 '13 at 09:17
  • 1
    Unfortunately, Lyx cannot be tricked into not loading a package. However, have you tried: (1) adding 2cell to Document Settings->Document Class->Custom? (2) adding \xyoption{2cell} to the preamble? – Daniel Feb 08 '13 at 19:29
  • @Daniel: \xyoption{2cell} does the trick, thanks! This would be an acceptable answer if you post it. – nonpop Feb 08 '13 at 20:00

2 Answers2

4

LyX has built-in support for xy and automatically adds a \usepackage[all]{xy} to the document's preamble, if the document makes use of xy features.

Unfortunately, LyX does not yet provide an interface to modify the options passed to automatically loaded packages; \PassOptionsToPackage does not work, as the user-defined preamble part comes after the LyX-generated part. Often passing them as extra options to the document class (in the text field found at Document Settings->Document Class->Custom) works, but this makes them being passed to all packages and seems to be not give the intended result for xy.

The xy package, however, also provides a "late" interface for package options via the \xyoption command. In this case adding

\xyoption{2cell}

to the document's preamble does the trick.

Daniel
  • 37,517
1

Okay, I found one way. If I put

\usepackage[all,2cell]{xy}
\UseTwocells
\newcommand{\xym}[1]{\xymatrix{#1}}

in the document preamble and use \xym instead of \xymatrix it works. This way I can't use the matrix editor, though, and it just feels too much of a hack (not to mention I have to change all existing \xymatrix commands), so if anyone comes up with a better solution, I'm still very much interested!

EDIT: Seems I don't have to use the \newcommand if I just use \xymatrix in an ERT box. But I still have to change the old \xymatrix commands and can't use the matrix editor...

nonpop
  • 153
  • if you are able to create a MWE of this issue, feel free to post an enhancement request at www.lyx.org/trac – scottkosty Feb 08 '13 at 09:51